Before the Holidays: November Book Thoughts


Honest book reviews by an indie author and reader

Ready for more book reviews from this Indie author?! I completed two relatively short reads, both under 200 pages. As always, these are books that I have personally read. I am sharing my honest opinion based on my reading experience and my knowledge as a writer. Here we go!

Title: Milk and Blood

Genre: Women’s Fiction?

Author: Jade Kim Monsen

I need to explain my question mark for the genre and my review moving forward. When I started with this book, I assumed that it was an autobiography or self-help book. Comments in the forward suggest that it is a fictional story. With that said, when I read this, I continued to associate the author as the storyteller, but she really isn’t. I would have liked to have a better forward from the author. It was written as a direct why, but for reasons I can’t explain, I couldn’t separate the fiction from the reality with this read. Here’s why.

The structure is written like a helpful guide. It is a lovely, raw, and real story about a woman’s journey from pre-motherhood, loss, and connectivity following a successful pregnancy and the breastfeeding journey. Monsen also includes segments that read like journal entries throughout the short read. It just reads like a personal journey. I don’t know exactly how much of this story is extracted from the author’s own journey, but it is shared in this story, more like a guide that would be highly advised to read if one is contemplating motherhood. It is all relatable and leaves nothing out of the conversation. Perfect Mother’s Day Gift or gift for a mom-to-be (Hint).


Title: Before the Storm Rises

Genre: Women’s Fiction/Romance

Author:  Nicola Hollingsworth 

Before The Storm Rises is a short read that is told in a two-person POV, oscillating between Jack (Jaqueline) and Seely. The reader is immediately exposed to Jack’s circumstances, a woman who works in a library, a job she often uses as an escape from  a domestic life that is as dreary as the winter call that is underlying in the first scene of the book. Jack is a victim of domestic abuse that includes dangerous control and emotional strangulation.

Almost immediately, we meet Seely, an old friend who is contemplating his life as a military serviceman. He is taking a break from service and encounters Jack at her workplace after years of disconnect. How will their relationship pan out?

This is a short read, less than 120 pages, and moves quickly as events happen throughout the plotline. Jack is written as a woman who is fluctuating between the emotions of losing her best friend, Seely, to military service, her misery and control dictated by her husband, Phillipe, and her own independence. In this flux with Jack, sometimes her actions came off as naive, but she would shift to a brave, independent woman, then shrink to a beaten, hopeless person. I think because of the length of the story, the accordion effect here of emotions for Jack made her range restricted. A longer story would allow for better transition and remove the moments that felt convenient, for example, her thinking of Seely and viola he was there in the room a few scenes later. There could be time for the Seely character to show the reader why he is doing what he is doing. The character Seely also has no time to show his full range, as the story is so short. So, when I read, he was played at a single level. 

Also, events need to happen fast due to the length of the story, so some of the main conflict feels like a blink. I always say, I don’t mind long stories, and this one I think really should have been longer in order to get the nuances and take Seely and Jack’s story to a richer level. It is a story of true love, protection, sacrifice, and the terrors of domestic abuse. Hollingsworth sets up a nice connection between Seely and Jack, including great chemistry. 

This was a fast read that had me despising the husband, feeling deeply for Jack, and rooting for a happily ever after. This one has not yet been published, but this author has a number of works available. Based on this read, I would recommend picking up one of Hollingsworth’s books.