Lauren’s Book Thoughts: October


Honest book reviews by a reader and writer

Title: Secrets of Milstone

Genre: Christian Fiction

Author: Katie R. Lindsey

Secrets of Milstone is a Christian Fiction novel, a genre that I don’t typically read. I read the book as it appeared on my Instagram feed and I wanted to support a small publisher and new author. 

Shanae our main character finds herself returning to her hometown Milstone after leaving when she was a teen. This comes after she loses her job and finds her long term boyfriend making out with her best friend. She is welcomed home with open arms by her parents, her father a lead pastor in a local church and her mother a devoted first wife. However, Shanae doesn’t let her family in to her secrets, especially those secrets that ran her away from Milstone. She sees her return to home as a needed rest from her troubles and goes back to where she grew up, the church. But then connections to her past make a pleasant pre-ordained path only God could lay before her. 

This is a long book. I don’t have a problem with long reads. But, this book is over 500 of pages long. It could have been shortened by not having so many mundane tasks described such as recipes, the same prayer made over every single meal eaten, orders made in restaurants and of course the sermons. There was also banter between some characters that did nothing to drive along the plot, it was just conversation that was not necessary to move things along. 

I went into this expecting to find certain elements, such as non-offensive language and themes about God’s grace and goodness. I also didn’t expect to see any spicy scenes between any characters. If anything, I anticipated a fade to black or simple pecks. Lindsey did something odd to me. She moved to have more intense kissing scenes bordering on spice but they became obnoxious. This is because she went into inserting the idea of lusting and sinning there. From a creative and storyline standpoint, this decision turned these scenes into awkward moments of judgement from the almighty and self-inflicting doubt on the character’s end. I think she could have done those scenes differently, more on the safe, clean innocent side which would make a loving relationship simply that, a loving, growing relationship, not an abomination or sinful. Additionally, the use of the word moaning was used to describe enjoying food, by several characters, which I felt was again to be strange, bordering on some innuendo maybe? Maybe not. It confused me. Was this a mild, Christian Fiction story or was it moving into a different genre? My final critical remark is based on the storyline itself. I figured out a number of the secrets relatively quickly.

Overall, the plus to this story is how the author tied Biblical principles, mainly faith in God and trust in God and of course, forgiveness to commonalities experienced by many people such as, making bad choices, keeping secrets, letting go, relationships, the good and the bad and more. It was a story of second chances, grace, and about how God’s love always prevails. I would recommend for those who enjoy Christian Fiction with a love story filled with deep kisses. LOL.